An officer from the Beijing Administration for Industry and Commerce (BAIC)
office speaks to journalists near fake or non-standard products on display at a
BAIC food safety monitoring center in Beijing in this June 12, 2007 file photo.
China has closed 180 food factories after inspectors found industrial chemicals
being used in products from candy to seafood, state media said Wednesday, June
27, 2007. (AP Photo/Ng Han Guan, File) Ng Han Guan: AP
ATLANTA — Thousands of tubes of contaminated Chinese-made
toothpaste were shipped to state prisons and mental hospitals in Georgia,
officials said Thursday, a sign that U.S. distribution of the tainted products
was wider than initially thought.
Officials with the state prison system and with the agencies that run mental
hospitals and juvenile detention centers said they knew of no health problems
stemming from the Chinese products.
They said the toothpaste contaminated with diethylene glycol, which is often
found in antifreeze, was immediately taken out of use as soon as federal
officials notified the state about the problem.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration advised consumers to "avoid using tubes
of toothpaste labeled as made in China," according to a statement posted on the
agency's Web site.
"Out of an abundance of caution, FDA suggests that consumers throw away
toothpaste labeled as made in China," the statement said.
Chinese-made toothpaste has been banned by numerous countries in Asia and the
Americas for containing diethylene glycol, or DEG. It is also a low-cost — and
sometimes deadly — substitute for glycerin, a sweetener in many drugs.
The New York Times reported Thursday that about 900,000 tubes have turned up
in the United States, including correctional facilities and some hospitals, not
just at discount stores as initially thought.
China insisted Thursday that the safety of its products was "guaranteed,"
making a rare direct comment on spreading international fears over tainted and
adulterated exports.
China "has paid great attention" to the safety of its exports, especially
food, because it concerns people's health, Commerce Ministry spokesman Wang
Xinpei said.
"It can be said that the quality of China's exports all are guaranteed," Wang
told reporters at a regularly scheduled briefing.
Rick Beal in the purchasing division of the Georgia Department of
Administrative Services told The Associated Press that cases of the tainted
Chinese toothpaste were sent to two state prisons, five state psychiatric
hospitals and four juvenile detention facilities.
The prison system was the largest consumer, with 5,877 cases. The hospitals
had 101 cases plus some loose tubes and the juvenile detention centers had 25
cases. Each case had 144 tubes.
Beal said that when the FDA notified the state about contamination with
diethylene glycol, the toothpaste was taken out of use.
"It's being stored," he said. "It's segregated from their operating supply.
'Do not use' signs are place on them. And they're pending disposition."
Tracy J. Smith, a spokeswoman for the Georgia Department of Corrections, said
the prison system had no reports of any health problems related to the
toothpaste.
Thomas Wilson, a spokesman for the Georgia Department of Human Resources,
which oversees the state's seven mental hospitals, said Thursday that after
getting the FDA advisory on June 8, the tubes of tainted toothpaste were
immediately pulled and replaced with name-brand toothpaste.
"We asked our clinical directors to be on the lookout for any signs of
poisoning or symptoms," Wilson said. "We've not have anybody ill. We are
continuing to monitor the situation."
Steve Hayes, a spokesman for the Georgia Department of Juvenile Justice, said
none of the youths in the agency's care was affected by the tainted
toothpaste.
"We pulled all the product immediately upon notification that there might be
a problem and we've continued to monitor the youth in our care," Hayes said.
"We've had no illnesses
A spokesman for North Carolina's Department of Correction told the Times that
Pacific brand toothpaste was distributed to prisoners who could not afford to
buy a name brand at prison stores. The tubes were taken away after trace amounts
of DEG was found in them. They said there had been no illnesses reported, and
that the toothpaste in question was being replaced with brands not manufactured
in China.
Chinese exports came under scrutiny earlier this year with the deaths of dogs
and cats in North America blamed on Chinese wheat gluten tainted with the
chemical melamine.
Since then, U.S. authorities have turned away or recalled toxic fish, juice
containing unsafe color additives and popular toy trains decorated with lead
paint.
On Wednesday, three Japanese importers recalled millions of Chinese-made
travel toothpaste sets, many sold to inns and hotels, after they were found to
contain as much as 6.2 percent of diethylene glycol.
Wang, the Chinese Commerce Ministry spokesman, said Chinese experts have
already "explained the situation."
He gave no details, although the country's quality watchdog has in past cited
tests from 2000 that it said showed toothpaste containing less than 15.6 percent
diethylene glycol was harmless to humans.
Also Wednesday, Beijing police raided a village where live pigs were
force-fed wastewater to boost their weight before slaughter, state media
reported.
Plastic pipes had been forced down the pigs' throats and villagers had pumped
each 220-pound pig with 44 pounds of wastewater, the Beijing Morning Post
reported Thursday.
Paperwork showed the pigs were headed for one of Beijing's main
slaughterhouses and stamps on their ears indicated that they already had been
through quarantine and inspection, the paper said. Suspects escaped during the
raid and no arrests were made, it said.
Earlier this week, inspectors announced they had closed 180 food factories in
China in the first half of this year and seized tons of candy, pickles, crackers
and seafood tainted with formaldehyde, illegal dyes and industrial wax.
"These are not isolated cases," Han Yi, an official with Wei's quality
administration, was quoted as saying in Wednesday's state-run China Daily
newspaper.
Han's admission was significant because the agency has said in the past that
safety violations were the work of a few rogue operators — a claim aimed at
protecting China's billions of dollars of food exports.
___